How to master the use of dropdown on your website
Dropdowns, or drop-down menus, are ubiquitous UI components, but their reputation in form design is not always the best. When poorly implemented, they can be confusing, impractical, and even frustrating for users. However, when used correctly, they become valuable tools that simplify interactions and organize options efficiently.
In this article, we explore the fundamental principles of dropdowns in forms, from their anatomy to their accessible implementation.
Anatomy of a dropdown
A dropdown consists of several basic elements. Similar to a text field, it includes:
- A visible label
- An interaction indicator (such as a chevron icon)
- The drop-down list that appears when the user interacts with it
This basic design ensures that users can identify it and understand its functionality at a glance.
Common dropdown variations
The standard dropdown is the most commonly used: a field that, when clicked, expands to show a list of options.
However, there are variations tailored to specific needs, such as:
- Dropdown with auto-suggestions: Allows users to search for options as they type.
- Dropdown with autocomplete: Suggests complete words or phrases, useful for long lists like country names or product catalogs.
- Dropdown with multiple selection: Allows users to select more than one option in a single field. While useful in some cases, it can be complex if not designed carefully.
A better alternative is grouping related elements within the dropdown, helping users locate options quickly and easily.
Visual design and dropdown states
From a visual perspective, dropdown styles can vary significantly.
- Standard rectangular borders → Functional and familiar
- Rounded borders → Provide a softer, more approachable feel in relaxed UI designs
- Icons or images → Can enhance the experience, but require careful maintenance
Dropdown states
Dropdowns must respond appropriately to user interaction:
- Active state → The dropdown must be clearly identifiable and intuitive to use.
- Disabled state → It should be visible but not clickable, signaling its inactivity without confusion.
- Hover state → Provides a clear indication that the element is interactive, especially important for desktop users.
- Focus state (Mobile Priority) → Highlights the dropdown when selected via keyboard or touch.
Strategic use of placeholder text
The placeholder text plays a crucial role. Phrases like “Select an option” are functional, but a more action-oriented text can better guide users.
For example:
- “Choose your country of residence” → Provides context and reduces uncertainty.
However, placeholders should never replace labels, as they disappear when users enter data, causing potential confusion.
When not to use a dropdown
It is important to recognize when a dropdown is not the best solution:
- If there are fewer than five options, radio buttons are a more direct alternative.
- For numerical values, text fields or sliders are often more practical.
- If the list is too long, a searchable dropdown with autocomplete is more efficient.
Accessibility and technical considerations
In terms of accessibility, dropdowns must comply with clear standards. This includes a minimum click size of 44px, color contrast that meets AAA guidelines, and a design that functions properly in both browsers and screen readers. Developers should also ensure that dropdowns can open upward or downward, depending on the available space in the browser window.
In situations where resources are limited, native dropdowns are a safe option. These come preconfigured in browsers, ensuring compatibility and functionality across multiple devices. An interesting alternative is the use of shells, where the field appears custom-designed, but upon interaction, it uses the native dropdown, combining style and usability.
In conclusion, dropdowns are powerful tools when used correctly. Their design should consider not only functionality but also accessibility and ease of use. Taking a thoughtful approach to their implementation ensures a smooth and satisfying experience for all users while maintaining efficiency in interaction and visual clarity in forms.
This is a translation of the following article from our corporate website:
